From their regular blog supermarketsinyourpocket.com, David Hughes, Emeritus Professor of Food Marketing at Imperial College London, and Miguel Flavián – who works for several Spanish organisations and companies via GM&Co to help them understand and respond to developments on the British grocery market – consider the potential likelihood of trial über hard discount supermarket easyFoodstore having any long-term commercial impact in the UK
You’ve got to keep on your toes in the UK grocery retail industry – sneak a weekend away in Berlin on the back of your trip to Fruit Logistica [held at the beginning of this month] and, on your return, another hard discounter has popped out of the undergrowth to nibble the nether regions of mainline supermarkets. Tesco’s Dave Lewis must be muttering “enough already” as he lowers himself gently on to his bed of nails!
Has Stelios spotted a gap in the market? His frank communications team say easyFoodstore targets food consumers who are poor, likely on benefits and have, as the economists say, a very low opportunity cost of their time.
Opening just three weeks ago, the trial store got huge publicity from the media. The shopping experience was described as “Soviet era” – stark “easy-orange” shelving, with 76 ambient products all priced at 25p ($0.35) for the opening month of February.
When we visited, there was a queue with an hour’s wait to get into the store. Later on the queue snaked around the corner and the wait time extended to five hours! The store was sold out by lunchtime and closed for restocking on two of the first five days of opening. There are no FMCG “A” brands, just Euroshopper and Best-in private label brands, available via Cash & Carry merchants.
Does this über-hard discount concept have longer-term commercial legs? Many in the grocery trade think it’s a characteristically-clever PR stunt from Stelios, which will expand to maybe a dozen stores and, then, wither away. But the very low income, benefit-assisted, time-rich, income-poor end of the market isn’t Scotch mist – it’s grown substantially through eight years of economic hard times and we’d be astonished if easyFoodstore shops weren’t spotted very soon in the big cities of northern England and over the border in west Scotland.
Sir Stelios Haji-Ioannou
The challenge in retailing is to fill in gaps in the mental maps of shoppers’ needs. Stelios believes there is a gap between food banks (free or, at least, subsidised food for households on benefits) and hard discounters. Aldi and Lidl have earned their low-price credentials and, now, are expanding their premium own label to attract a higher income shopper and reward existing shoppers wanting a treat. Miguel bought his haunch of jamón Ibérico from Lidl at Christmas for an attractive price of £99.99!
The austere easy-orange shops may well appeal to beleaguered shoppers who view Aldi, Lidl and even Poundland as beyond their means. We wouldn’t be surprised if Stelios capitalised on this Robin Hood-esque “friend of the poor” market position and to use end production runs, safe but slightly damaged, close to use-by-date products, etc. as exclusive offers to those who can prove their on-benefit status.
In an era of savvy shoppers and bashing plutocratic bankers, there is more likely to be a “Badge of Honour” than a “Badge of Shame” associated with being a family reliant on state benefits and, as a result, shoppers can enter the orange portals of easyFoodstore with their heads held high!
Market growth in grocery is exceedingly challenging and who’d have thought that the likes of Asda/Walmart would be celebrating that its current dark days of sales downturns are close to over. The company is still losing market share – that’s a reason to celebrate?!
In mature grocery markets where big supermarkets have the majority share, any new company entering, however small it may be, will nibble away at their toes and ensure that grocery retail price wars will remain pervasive.
When Stelios launched easyJet in 1995, the established airlines (not least British Airways) dismissed it as a minor irritant. Now, easyJet has a higher market cap [market capitalization] than any of them!
We don’t believe easyFoodstore is going to rock the retail boat significantly, but it will contribute in some small way to the likes of Tesco’s Dave Lewis sharpening his retail price pencil through the remainder of the decade.
Watch this video on the launch of easyFoodstore: